However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. And casati and varzi do have much more to say about holes, more indeed than can receive mention in this brief note. His first book, holes and other superficialities 1994, with roberto casati, was an exploration of the realist ontology of common sense and. Varzi address some of the fundamental issues in the philosophy of spatial representation. Two books with mit press contain the main results of that work. The work on holes originated at a summer school in 1989 in which i attended a course on logic on supervaluations taught by achille varzi.
As a development of some of those strands of research, i now working on navigation, the phenomenology of disorientation, and on our understanding of maps. Holes and other superficialities casati, roberto, varzi, achille c. The structures of spatial representation and holes and other superficialities. Indeed, the fact that holes are not made of anything seems to be a major hindrance to giving adequate identity. The hardcover of the holes and other superficialties by roberto casati, achille c. Apr 27, 2000 for all their importance, however, holes are slippery, elusive entities, say authors roberto casati and achille c. Mit press and the author of the discovery of the shadow knopf, translated in 8 languages. Mereology, oxford, oxford university press, fothcoming abstract. Holes and other superficialities bradford books roberto casati, achille c. Guangzhou, guangdong peoples publishing house, forthcoming. Whats a hole made of and other enigmas interview by richard marshall.
His books include holes and other superficialities and parts and places both with r. To put it differently, if one has enjoyed holes, one will appreciate parts and places even more. Abigail asher translator is an editor of art history and other nonfiction books. Surfaces belong to geometry, not physics koenderink, 1990, and in this sense holes cannot be treated in a purely materialistic way. Sul confine tra ontologia e metafisica on the boundary between ontology and metaphysics, giornale di metafisica, 29 2007. Parts, locations, and holes formal reasoning about.
I went into a phd program, i lived the life of a phd student in philosophy, and i eventually wrote a dissertation. Varzi this fascinating investigation on the borderlines of metaphysics, everyday geometry, and the theory of perception seeks to answer two basic questions. Achille varzi is associate professor of philosophy at columbia university, new york. In his book casati seeks to break down the mystery of shadows and to reconcile their mystique with their scientific function. So begins insurmountable simplicities, roberto casati and achille varzi s colorful incarnation of the many philosophical conundrums that hide in the wrinkles of everyday life. Mar 24, 2011 discover book depositorys huge selection of achille c varzi books online. Mereology can be viewed as a type of formal philosophy, and casati and varzi are most definitely highly competent philosophers writing in the relaxed manner of contemporary english language philosophy. Holes and other superficialities by roberto casati 1994. His first book, holes and other superficialities 1994, with roberto casati, was an exploration of the realist ontology of common sense and naive physics. Achille varzi columbia university, ny cu department. Casati and varzi argue in favor of their existence and explore the consequences of this unorthodox approachodd as these might appear. We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. As casati and varzis book shows, thinking holes is thinking reality itself, questioning the relation between something and nothing which we usually take for granted. Roberto casati and achille varzi, parts and places, mit press, cam bridge, mass.
Article discusses philosophical theory put forth in book holes and other superficialities by roberto casati and achille varzi. He has taught at several universities in europe and us. Roberto casati italian academy for advanced studies. Achille varzi on philosophy and the academy gadfly. Casati and varzi explore the ins and outs of the metaphysics of holes, one of the lesser kinds with brio, much learning lightly worn and a. They could, however, be true, and the reader is invited to ponder this. Nov 18, 2000 article discusses philosophical theory put forth in book holes and other superficialities by roberto casati and achille varzi.
Jan 15, 1994 holes and other superficialities book. Holes and other superficialities bradford books roberto. Varzi is also a prolific writer for the general public and contributes regularly to several italian newspapers. Holes and other superficialities and parts and places. There is no such thing as a hole by itself, tucholsky 1931. Since his first book, holes and other superficialities 1996, with casati, varzi displayed a unique philosophical style. Varzi is currently an editor of the journal of philosophy and an advisory editor of the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Indeed, the fact that holes are not made of anything seems to be a major hindrance to giving adequate. It is also difficult to assess the explanatory relevance of. Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. We develop and formally describe a basic ontology consisting of the mutually disjoint primitives solid object, hole and boundary.
The book had its genesis while casati was watching a lunar eclipse, when he realized that shadows, usually thought of as concealing or hiding things, in fact have the power to reveal. Varzi propose in their book holes and other superficialities that our easiest way out is to argue that, by holes, we actually mean holed objects, the material that the holes are in p. Unlocking their secrets, from plato to our time by. Yet we seem to be able to perceive holes, gaps, dents and the like. Jun 28, 2001 we propose an ontology engineering framework for the anatomy domain, focusing on mereotopological properties of parts, locations and empty spaces holes. Varzi achille casati, roberto and varzi, achille 1994 holes and other superficialities casati, roberto 2003 the shadow club trans. Varzi in their book holes and other superficialities. Mereology, the study of parts and wholes, has become increasingly popular. Either holes are somehow material, or else there are no such things. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle.
Roberto casati is a tenured senior researcher with the french cnrs at the ecole normale superieure in paris. With achille varzi he is the author of holes and other superficialities and parts and places. Varzi holes and other superficialities, mit press cambridge, ma, 1994. These nonfacts allow us to take a fresh look at the world.
Mereologythe formal theory of parthood relationshas become a chapter of central interest not only in metaphysics but also in logic, the philosophy of mathematics, and the philosophy of science, which is to say in every field where partwhole theorizing plays a fundamental role. Insurmountable simplicities columbia university press. He began delving into the ways in which ancient and modern philosophers, astronomers, and artists have manipulated and understood shadows. His more recent work is inspired by a nominalistconventionalist stance.
Voti e altri buchi elettorali ballots and other polling holes with roberto casati, rivista di estetica, 48. Holes and other superficialities by roberto casati, achille c. Holes and other superficialties by roberto casati, achille. The present book is not the continuation of holes, rather it takes a broader perspective, using holes when necessary to explain spatial peculiarities, but providing a lot of different examples too. But to be noted that i am not against the digital at large. And casati and varzi do have much more to say about holes, more indeed. Parts and places is an excellent university level introduction to this theory, known as mereology. Varzi born may 8, 1958, galliate is an italianborn philosopher. The book has over 150 pictures and is completed by a formal appendix, a section with puzzles and exercises, and a extensive annotated.
Holes and other superficialities by roberto casati 19940115 roberto casati. I developed small instructional apps and software for elementary astronomy. Holes are an interesting case study for ontologists and epistemologists. At the same summer school kit fine introduced identity issues by presenting borderline cases of two distinct entities, such as two distinct shadows, that can occupy the same region of space. Roberto casati, achille varzi perhaps not all the stories that follow are true. Holes pose something of a philosophical quandary and, perhaps as a result of their mystery, are often treated as immaterial entities casati and varzi 1994. A 20 book against digital colonialism in italian, translated in french and in spanish defends the precautionary principle for the use of digital technologies in educational settings. He is the author of the shadow club and with achille varzi parts and places. It is difficult to put ones finger on what a hole is. A bradford book most work in metaphysics concentrates on the more abstract kinds of entities substances, universals and events. Holes and other superficialities by roberto casati, 97802625337. Arguably, whenever a physical interaction can be explained by appeal to the concept of a hole, a matching explanation can be offered invoking only material objects and their properties. Discover book depositorys huge selection of achille c varzi books online. Achille varzi is professor of philosophy at columbia university.
May 03, 2017 black holes are, therefore, the other way around. They argue against a purely materialistic approach to shape, and holes are the perfect example of an entity that exists. Varzi, 9780262032117, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. They examine the ontology of holes, their geometry, their partwhole relations, their identity, their causal role, and the ways we perceive them. A brief introduction to the main philosophical problems and theories about the nature of holes and suchlike nothingnesses. Casati and varzi argues in favour of holes existence, examining their. Varzi is currently an editor of the journal of philosophy and an advisory editor of the stanford encyclopedia of. For all their importance, however, holes are slippery, elusive entities, say authors roberto casati and achille c. Casati and varzi explore the ins and outs of the metaphysics of holes, one of the lesser kinds with brio, much learning lightly worn and a number of excellent arguments and distinctions. We propose an ontology engineering framework for the anatomy domain, focusing on mereotopological properties of parts, locations and empty spaces holes. Fantasies and reflections on self and soul, new york.
1101 836 1529 393 59 1147 766 16 1536 1200 313 1122 534 1579 1563 214 1260 1020 1555 71 1417 1132 11 37 1023 380 151 944 464 602 1293 1170 322 162 88 838 1272 566 164 28 505 1114 342 1000 1322 529 885 361 418